The world is experiencing an overfishing crisis, one-third of which can be blamed on China (pdf). Nevertheless, the Chinese demand for fishing products keeps increasing as Chinese consumers are switching from grain-based diets to animal proteins. In combination with the pursuit of economic interest of fishermen and fishing companies, a new growth policy was implemented in 2010. The growth policy is supported by generous fuel subsidies, which aim to expand the sector even more. This is a surprise to many since the country experienced a zero-growth period between 2000 and 2010 (see figure 1). At that time, policies were implemented to halt further damages to local fishery grounds caused by overfishing and destructive fishing practices like bottom trawlers.
|Figure 1. China’s Annual Marine Catch Production|
Why are West African nation’s not doing enough to avoid the depletion of their coastal fisheries? First, due to the difficulty of detecting Illegal, Unregulated and Unreported (IUU) fishing practices. Second, the West African coast is known as "the Wild West" of the sea where law enforcement is weak. But more importantly, West African nations have a high economic dependence on the Chinese DWF agreements that are in place. The legal DWF are nonetheless impactful since China’s licensed footprint is twice the size of the entire DWF fleet of the United States. As West African countries are still developing, they depend on licensing money and aid packages. For example, in Mauritania, DWF fees make up 27% of the total national budget. This means that if they are too harsh on overfishing and/or harmful fishing practices, they could face severe economic consequences.
Governments from China and West African countries need to understand that fishing unsustainably for economic interest will harm their countries in the long run. As the West African waters are also depleting, it will not take long before Chinese DWF will lose their jobs or will have to find other fishing grounds to deplete. Also, West African nations will lose the rent they collect from selling fishing licensing as well as their profitable fishing industry, thereby destabilizing their economies even more.
Bottom Line China and West African nations have both created dependencies on marine resources. From past experience, China should take the responsibility and start changing is fishing practices. Short term gains over less developed countries in West Africa will backfire. Without West-African nation’s capacity to intervene, soon one of the most fertile fishing grounds of the world will be gone.
* Please comment on these posts from my environmental economics students, to help them with unclear analysis, alternative perspectives, better data, etc.