22 Jan 2015

Everyday bounded rationality

I took this photo at a California supermarket. It displays the price for a 24-bottle pack of Nestle water.

Let's figure out which price applies to you...

This 24-pack is...
$3.99 if you buy one with a loyalty card
$4.99 if you buy one without a loyalty card
$2.99 if you buy 5 packs (120 bottles) with a card

...but make sure you add sales tax (8 percent in this county) and CRV (bottle deposit), which varies by container size. I'm not sure, but I'd guess that a purchase of a single 24-pack, without card, would cost $(4.99*1.08)+(24*0.05) = $6.59, or more than double the screaming $2.99 price...

So, is this normal? Let's look at the Dutch version of things:

It says € 1.67 for 6 bottles of 500ml water, at a cost of € 0.56/liter. (I can't even tell how many ounces or liters comes with the 24 bottles above.) That's the tax and (no) deposit-inclusive price, btw.

Bottom Line: In some countries, stores sell you goods. In others, they sell you a bill of goods. Perhaps that confusion explains why Americans are so (fatally) abusive of drugs (compared to the Dutch).

1 comment:

  1. Oh boy, gotta love shopping in the US of A.

    Let's make some educated guesses. The picture says 28/16.9FO. Let's assume that 28=$0.28*, and that FO means fluid ounces. 16.9 fluid ounces is (essentially) .5 liters. (at 33.8 ounces per liter, neglecting decimal dust). So, if theses guess are correct, this mega-store is asking $0.56/liter water (and plastic, packaging and all of the other bonus nonsense included around the water.)

    Pushing this a bit farther, a price point of $4.99, at $0.56/liter, yields 9 liters per flat of 24 bottles. Each bottle would hold .375 liters of water or 12.69 fluid ounces. This is a common size for may of Nestle's products- perrier, poland spring, arrowhead, ice mountain, and san pelligrino (less sure on the last one).

    So, if $4.99 for 9 liters is $0.56/liter,
    then $3.99/9 liters is $0.44/liter and
    $2.99 for 9 liters is $0.33/liter (minimum of 45 liters).

    At .88EUR/USD, those numbers are:
    (w/o card): 64 EUR/liter
    (w/card): .5 EUR/liter
    (w/card, bulk buy and small truck): .375 EUR/liter

    *Before all of you math geeks go wacko, I believe this number is actually $0.277/16.9 fluid ounces. The arithmetic works our well enough and matches actual bottle sizes in the US of A.


Read this first!

Make sure you copy your comment before submitting because sometimes the system will malfunction and you will lose your comment.

Spam will be deleted.

Comments on older posts must be approved (do not submit twice).

If you're having problems posting, email your comment to me