23 May 2011

Poll results -- transnational waters

Hey! There's a new poll (regulation and oversight) on the sidebar ====>
Trans-national waters are most likely to...
...facilitate peaceful cooperation between countries 38%25
...instigate hostilities between countries 58%38
...should not exist (redraw national borders) 3%2


A majority believe that transnational waters are more likely to spur conflict that cooperation. There are a number of examples of conflict (Israel and neighbors,* India and Pakistan, China and everyone, etc.), but most of these conflicts are "under control" through negotiations, agreements, etc.

In fact, there are very few examples of conflict OVER waters (the 1967 Six Day war, among them), and a number of examples of cooperation based on the necessity of sharing waters.

We probably pay more attention to conflicts that stick in our minds (and serve the rhetorical needs of politicians) than pragmatic "making do" cooperation.

Bottom Line: Transboundary waters can help neighbors build good relations, but populist demagogues prefer to use them to stir nationalist hatred of "others" (often for the benefit of domestic special interests).
* The Swiss recently released a report on Water and peace in the Middle East [pdf]

No comments:

Post a Comment

Spam will be deleted. Comments on older posts must be approved.
If you're having problems posting, email your comment to me