16 Sep 2010

Auctions for ecosystem services

Sandor Toth sent me his article [pdf] on auctioning a single choice from a range of management alternatives. For example, the decision to clear-cut or maintain or selectively harvest a forest. This ECOSEL auction mechanism improves on regulations, i.e.,
We also like to emphasize that ECOSEL is a voluntary mechanism that provides a platform for both potential sellers and potential buyers of ecosystem services to freely express their intrinsic motivation. It givesmore freedom to individuals to influence forest management decisions on public or private lands via monetary contributions. More control is also given to the sellers (the forest landowners) because with ECOSEL, they have the option to try to raise dollars for management plans that they cannot afford otherwise. They are in full control because it is up to them to decide which management plans, if any, should be put up for auction. In contrast to regulations that can reward provisions or penalize non-provisions of ecosystem services, it can be argued that ECOSEL is an intervention that crowds in intrinsic motivation.
This method should be studied by people interested in low-cost, socially-efficient mechanisms for making policies that affect public or common pool goods. (Also see the last sections of this article [pdf] on options for the Sac-SJ Delta for my version of a solution.)

1 comment:

  1. The pdf is a very interesting article.
    It has one complexity that will take me a while to understand.
    An ecosystem is not just its megafauna--trees and large animals. It is thousands of species covering many square miles and multiple owners. It changes over time in many ways.

    If you auction 'the views', what have you actually auctioned? Is it the trees, the ferns, the arrangement of chipmunks, the lack of human change on this parcel of land but not human change elicited by a change on the next parcel of land or on a parcel of land somewhere else in a watershed?

    Legally, selling a local part of a time dependent ecosystem might lead to many many law suits as the ecosystem changed.

    More thoughts later as I start to understand the economics and how it might interact with the thousands of species of a real world ecosystem.


Read this first!

Make sure you copy your comment before submitting because sometimes the system will malfunction and you will lose your comment.

Spam will be deleted.

Comments on older posts must be approved (do not submit twice).

If you're having problems posting, email your comment to me