23 Oct 2008

The Political Economy of Cap and Trade

I just did a presentation [PDF] on carbon cap and trade. In it, I spoke in favor of carbon taxes and against cap and trade (for fear of the political manipulations that are all-too-likely).*

In particular, I highlighted the importance of taxing carbon as close to the source as possible, the necessity of rebating ALL tax revenue (or auction revenue, should C&T be enacted) to citizens, and the importance of allowing price signals (HIGHER PRICES) to work.

I did the presentation at the annual meeting of the National Association of [Investor-Owned] Water Companies [site]. NAWC is worried that carbon taxes/C&T will increase the cost of delivering water -- as it should -- and that revenue from taxes/C&T will be rebated to "favored" industries (e.g., municipally-owned water companies) -- as it should NOT.

When preparing the talk, I was surprised to learn that the EPA's SO2 auctions (the famously-successful ones that have been running since 1995) account for less than 3% of total SO2 permit activity. 97% of permits are given to industry -- and then traded.

Bottom Line: We should tax carbon like we tax gasoline: Taxes are simple, transparent and hard to manipulate. We should then rebate the the $billions (trillions?) in tax revenue to citizens, not "favored" industries.

* For more debate, see this

1 comment:

  1. David,
    Are you aware of this?
    I am non-committal about choosing between C&T and a carbon tax, and think that each has its own merits and demerits. Economists argue that a tax will be more efficient than a trading system, but IMO, this does not spur innovation. Giving tax rebates to people might make them consume more of the same..On the other hand, a carbon tax might be more simpler than a complex piece of C&T legislation.

    ReplyDelete

Read this first!

Make sure you copy your comment before submitting because sometimes the system will malfunction and you will lose your comment.

Spam will be deleted.

Comments on older posts must be approved (do not submit twice).

If you're having problems posting, email your comment to me