24 Mar 2008

The Long Emergency

A prescient article from 2005 that discusses the future of energy and makes some dire predictions:
America is in a special predicament due to a set of unfortunate choices we made as a society in the twentieth century. Perhaps the worst was to let our towns and cities rot away and to replace them with suburbia, which had the additional side effect of trashing a lot of the best farmland in America. Suburbia will come to be regarded as the greatest misallocation of resources in the history of the world. It has a tragic destiny. The psychology of previous investment suggests that we will defend our drive-in utopia long after it has become a terrible liability.


The circumstances of the Long Emergency will require us to downscale and re-scale virtually everything we do and how we do it, from the kind of communities we physically inhabit to the way we grow our food to the way we work and trade the products of our work. Our lives will become profoundly and intensely local. Daily life will be far less about mobility and much more about staying where you are.


Some regions of the country will do better than others in the Long Emergency. The Southwest will suffer in proportion to the degree that it prospered during the cheap-oil blowout of the late twentieth century. I predict that Sunbelt states like Arizona and Nevada will become significantly depopulated, since the region will be short of water as well as gasoline and natural gas. Imagine Phoenix without cheap air conditioning.
We are lucky that we can even buy gas at $3.50/gallon. If markets are disrupted (by outside suppliers or foolish intervention by our government), we may see no gas at all or black market gas. Now extend that scenario to other energy sources.

Bottom Line: The best thing we can have are deep and robust markets in energy. That means no subsidies and normalized taxes (e.g., on carbon or per unit of energy). On the international scene, we want to keep Iran, Russia, Angola and other dodgy places in the market (not necessarily with US companies or weapons). Given those two conditions, we will be able to adjust to the long emergency using market forces and innovation (BEST CASE). Anything less, and we get gratuitous pain.


  1. It seems as if the solution (or perhaps the path is semi-lighted and we just to follow it and see where it takes us) is right there in front of us but we just can't seem to escape from the fangs of special interest/lobbyists and the other usual suspects.

    So what to do? Anyone with a pulse can see the problem but how do you turn all of this into action?


  2. 1) End subsidies to energy use. Everyone understands "lower taxes."
    2) End subsidies on energy technologies. Governments cannot pick winners.
    3) Tax consumption of energy uses that everyone (majority) agrees are "bad" - this means WV coal (sulfur) and *could* mean imported oil (security) and anything that produces carbon.
    4) Pay attention to market structure/monopolies.

    Then let the market figure out the rest.

  3. I think this is what I was trying to get at.

    So we know the stylized response to the problems but why can't we implement these things? We see the dots but just can't seem to connect them.

    Why does persist?

  4. Read the Logic of Collective Action (Olson) to understand why its hard to organize a large group to fight a smaller group...

    The internet is faciltating collective action, so "we" are finding ways to overcome the difficulties.

    Imagine how hard it is to counter fraud with secret voting. Nobody knows the results except a few, and they can manipulate them (or the Diebold voting machines).

    Then consider the way that internet users all over the US collaborated to find which senator put a stop on debating a bill on transparency (no surprise, it was that idiot from Alaska -- Stevens).

    Read this

    So the internets are a good thing :)


Read this first!

Make sure you copy your comment before submitting because sometimes the system will malfunction and you will lose your comment.

Spam will be deleted.

Comments on older posts must be approved (do not submit twice).

If you're having problems posting, email your comment to me